Layout of Thoughts on Deuteronomy 6:4
A reference chart or list rather than an essay.
יהוה אלהינו יהוה אהד
“Yahveh our God is one Yahveh.”
“Yahveh is our God, Yahveh alone.”
“Yahveh is our God, Yahveh is one.”
“Yahveh is our God; Yahveh is unique.”
A Jewish A Jewish
Viewpoint Response Response Counter-response
Deuteronomy 6:4 “us” (a) majestic plural Genesis 3:22* “one of us”
does not mean majestic plural;
it is the clearest Old Testament
text on plurality associated
with trinitarian deity.
one = single Genesis 1:26; (b) angels + God = “us” (1) Angels not yet mentioned
being *3:22; 11:7 in Genesis. Genesis 3:24
(Isaiah 6:8) refers to them later (note
Job 38:7 and 1:6 however).
(2) Besides, in the statement of
fulfillment after the
proposal in Genesis 1:26,
the text affirms that it is in
the image of God.
(3) It is in his image (i.e., not
plural as one would expect
if “us” in 1:26 meant God +
angels).
Deuteronomy 6:4: (1) The “Shema” needs to contri- bute to our loving God com- pletely. That he is a single being vs. a trinity does not give a reason for
loving him. The point is rather that one means “unique,” or “only one” (no
other gods); both ideas can contribute to reasons for loving him.
(2) אֶהָד (“one”) does not eliminate distinction between the sub-units
of what is “one.” A good example is Genesis 2:24, where husband +
wife = אֶהָד (“one”) flesh.
Note: The preferred translation of Deuteronomy 6:4 is “Yahveh is our God, Yahveh alone.”
